How the media should deal with information about the health of public figures remains a contentious issue in many countries. Many news outlets subscribe to the view that private lives should remain private unless public trust is broken or when private actions conflict with public positions. Controversy emerges over the exposure of marital infidelities, but it is in the area of health that agreement is hardest to achieve on where the dividing line should be between the public's right to know and a public figure's right to privacy. This article deals with the experience in Ireland in late 2009 when the broadcast of information about the health of the country's Finance Minister became a matter of controversy. The discussion examines this specific case before exploring the wider ethical issues, which have universal applicability. © 2013 Copyright Taylor and Francis Group, LLC.